Insure Your Needs
Let us help you find the right coverage.
Get Started
Auto Insurance
Explore all the options available to you.
Get Started
Home Insurance
Let us assist you in selecting the best coverage.
Get Started
Business Insurance
We get you the right coverage for the right price.
Get Started
RV Insurance
Get free quotes and dedicated personal service.
Get Started

Welcome to Main Street Insurance Agency, LLC


We are an Independent Insurance Agency, which means we have made available some of our best companies for your online quick quotes. We service clients in the Tulsa and Sapulpa Oklahoma areas. At Main Street Insurance Agency, LLC, each one of our clients is given a dedicated team that works together to proficiently address all your concerns. We offer all types of Personal Insurance coverages to our clients in Oklahoma, including Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Individual Life Insurance,Motorcycle Insurance, and Boat & Watercraft. Give one of our agents a call to save money on your Business Insurance. Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Business Owners Policy (BOP), General Liability, Commercial Auto, Workers Compensation, and Commercial Property. Let us help you cut your insurance cost in Oklahoma Just give us a quick call today at 918-224-6600 or make your request here.

Instant Insurance Quote

In a hurry? Get a quote on your insurance policy instantly!

Get Started!
Get an instant quote today!
American Modern Logo
BHHC Logo
CCA Logo
Falcon Logo
Farmers Mutual Logo
Foremost Logo
Gainsco Logo
GEICO Logo
Hallmark Logo
Main Street America Logo
Markel Logo
MDOW Logo
Mercury Logo
National General Logo
National Lloyds Logo
National Security Group Logo
Progressive Logo
Safeco Logo
Traders Logo
Travelers Logo
USLI Logo
Warrior Logo

What our customers say

This is the place to go

-Nick

Great provider. Personal service.

-Winston

Love the ladies. They are always so nice. I always recommend this place.

-Amanda

I have had good results with main street sapulpa five stars all day

-Ronnie

Everything is very good pleasant folks will work hard to get the best rates possible

-John

Main st insurance is a great insurance provider, affordable prices. Customer service is always top notch.

-Eilin

Really Great place to get insurance coverage on anything.... Great employees that are wonderful & help you out on any questions on anything you need.

-Valery

Brian and team have always provided a great service and work hard to find the right coverage for my needs.

-Jay

Excellent personalized service. Brian always provides us with great service and rates!

-Eric

Brian Newnam is an awesome agent. He goes above and beyond to help you and to find the best policies for you.

-Darlene

Great prices and great people. They are always available and get what I need done done and within great time. I’m not sitting around for an hour like most places

-Cheyennes

Very knowledgeable, fast service and very kind, I’ve been with this insurance agency almost two years and I’ve never had one problem with them, and they know how to save you money

-Nellie

Made one phone call to such a awesome insurance agency. Quickly after give them my info insurance was reduced $45 per month. Recommend them to any one.

-Larry

I am so excited Main Street Insurance helped me find the best quote for my RV! So happy with the coverage and rate! Always satisfied with Main Street Insurance!

-G.

I worked with BJ Taber today and she was very quick to getting back to me and taking excellent care of me and would definitely send someone there way ! Surprised me today with a great deal that I didn’t expect and met all my needs and can’t thank them...

-Josh

I've had all of my insurance coverage with this agency for many years and am very pleased with the customer service, as well as the best premiums and they are able to shop several carriers for the best rates available. Highly recommend! Positive Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

-Jalie

Very professional and helpful. I went to them for home insurance, but ended up bundling everything through Main Street because they were able to get me the best rates imaginable. I worked directly with Brian and he knows his stuff and is incredibly responsive. Positive Responsiveness, Quality, Professionalism, Value

-Anthony

I'm so thankful for Brian helping us insure both our vehicles and home. He found us the best rates with the best coverage. He is very proffessional, quick and willing to answer any questions and we couldn't be more pleased to have him as our new agent. We found out...

-Cassidy

I’ve been using them for two and a half years. They’re always so helpful. Recently I moved to Tulsa and my insurance went up, but Brian was able to find me a new agency with dramatically lower prices. Thank you guys for always helping me out!

-Rainey

Great company and people. They've been handling all our insurance needs perfectly. They are not tied to one Insurance Company, so they can provide full range of services. We have our commercial liability, homeowners, cars, trailers etc. all insured with one agent but different Insurance Companies. Highly recommended!

-Tomasz

Leave us a review

The greatest testament that our customers can provide is by sharing their experience.

View More

Our latest articles

Read More
Located in Sapulpa, Oklahoma.We also serve the Jenks, Kellyville, Kiefer, Sand Springs, and Tulsa areas.Licensed in Oklahoma

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

©2026. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites